Why 'Clean and Modern' Is the Most Expensive Brief You Can Give
If you've ever asked a designer or illustrator for something "clean and modern," you may have been surprised by the cost, or the results. That phrase feels like it should make things easier. In reality, it often leads to generic, uninspired work that fails to connect with your audience.
Here's why, and what to do instead.
What “clean and modern” actually produces
The exact template I use with my clients.
When your brief says "make it look clean and modern," you're handing a designer a blank canvas and asking them to fill it with vague ideals. The result is usually predictable: visuals that could belong to any brand, designs that lack personality or purpose, and endless revision rounds because your designer is essentially guessing at what you want.
This isn't a reflection of skill. It's a reflection of direction, or the lack of it. Guess wrong once, and you're already spending more time and money than the brief was ever worth.
The fix starts with a better brief.
A story-led brand brief gives your designer clarity, direction, and the context they need to create work that's made for you, not guessed for you.
A note on neutrals (because beige gets a bad rap)
There’s a common assumption that “clean and modern” means cool greys, stark whites, and stripped-back minimalism. But neutrals, like warm beiges, earthy tones, and soft off-whites, are not boring. Used intentionally, they are some of the most sophisticated and versatile tools in a designer’s palette. The problem was never the colour. The problem is using any aesthetic without a reason behind it. A story-led brief fixes that.
What a Story-Led Brief Produces
A story-led brief gives your designer context, personality, and clear direction. Instead of describing an aesthetic, it uncovers the why behind your project. Here are four questions worth answering before any creative work begins:
Here are four questions worth answering before any creative work begins:
Who are we speaking to?
Understanding your audience shapes tone, style, and approach.What feeling do we want to evoke?
Design isn’t just visual, it’s emotional. Knowing the feeling helps the designer choose the right colors, imagery, and composition.What makes our brand or story unique?
Identifying your differentiators ensures your visuals stand out instead of blending in.What’s the purpose of this piece?
Every design or illustration should have a clear goal, whether it’s building trust, showcasing expertise, or telling a story.
How this applies to brand projects and illustration commissions
The principle holds whether you're briefing a full brand strategy project or commissioning a single illustration. A story-led brief reduces wasted revisions, produces work that's memorable and effective, and makes the investment worthwhile because every design decision has a reason behind it.
For a brand project, this might mean your brief includes audience insights, messaging pillars, and visual tone of voice. For an illustration, it could outline the narrative, key characters, and the emotion you want the viewer to feel.
The takeaway
"Clean and modern" isn't wrong, it's just not enough. Swapping vague descriptors for story-led direction turns your brief from a guessing game into a roadmap.
Before your next brand or illustration project, answer those four questions. You'll save time, reduce costs, and end up with work that actually means something.
NEXT STEPS
Download our Services Guide
Our Services Guide gives you a clear overview of how we work, what's included at each stage, and what to expect when you partner with us.
What’s included is a full breakdown of our services, brand audit, brand strategy, visual identity, and messaging. Details on our process from initial questionnaire through to final delivery.
Want to get all the juicy goss about branding and illustration straight to your inbox?
Sign up for the newsletter and receive monthly newsletters!
Just like Mr Magorium’s Wonder Emporium, where we share a variety of (branding and illustration) tips that bridges the gap between designers and business owners.
